Catchweight

Grills, Smokers, and Pizza showdown

The Best Kamado Grills (2026): The Egg Is Not Cheaper, and the Warranty Depends on Who Sold It

By The Smith Family, reviewed by Brad Smith · Independent, no paid placement · Updated October 16, 2026Prices checked September 2026

Some links here are affiliate links — if you buy through them, we may earn a commission at no extra cost to you (sometimes with a discount for you). It never changes which products we recommend — and we name the SKIPs to prove it.

Every kamado buyer’s guide we read reaches the same conclusion: the Kamado Joe Classic Joe II wins, the Big Green Egg is the runner-up, and they all cook beautifully. We agree about the cooking. Consumer Reports put seven kamados in a lab and found they all make great food, which is worth saying plainly because it removes the thing most guides spend their word count on.

If the cooking does not separate the field, three other things do: what the grill costs once it can actually cook, who sold it to you, and what arrives in the crate. We read every contender’s owner reviews signed in on Amazon, the critical ones first, and the makers’ own warranty documents, and we split the field by size, because a 13-inch grill for two and a 24-inch grill for a crowd are not the same purchase.

Quick comparison

Model	Best for	Body	Cooking area	Weight	Warranty	Owner rating	Price
Kamado Joe Classic Joe II 18-inch	The one that arrives rigged	Ceramic	~250 sq in (18 in)	227.7 lb	Ceramic lifetime; metal and cast iron 5 yr; deflectors, stones and electronics 3 yr; thermometer and GASKETS 2 yr	4.7★ / 975	Check price →
Kamado Joe Classic Joe I 18-inch	The $1,000 way into a Kamado Joe	Ceramic	250 sq in (18 in)	188 lb (Amazon detail table)	Ceramic lifetime; metal and cast iron 5 yr; deflectors, stones and electronics 3 yr; thermometer and GASKETS 2 yr	4.6★ / 360	Check price →
Char-Griller AKORN 20-inch Kamado Charcoal Grill	Kamado shape, steel body, a third of the price	Triple-wall insulated steel — NOT ceramic	325 sq in main / 445 sq in with warming rack	88.2 lb	5-year burn and rust-through; registration required; original purchaser only; EXCLUDES surface rust	4.6★ / 2,356	Check price →
Big Green Egg Large in Nest Package	The name, and the warranty you have to read	Ceramic	262 sq in	162 lb	Ceramic limited lifetime; grate, grid, rEGGulator, band and hinge 5 yr; convEGGtor and baking stones 3 yr. Conditions below.		~$1,499.99typical at Big Green EggCheck price →
Kamado Joe Classic Joe III 18-inch	The three-tier Classic, with the SloRoller in the box	Ceramic	250 sq in (18 in)	280.6 lb	Ceramic lifetime; metal and cast iron 5 yr; deflectors, stones and electronics 3 yr; thermometer and GASKETS 2 yr	4.5★ / 267	Check price →
Kamado Joe Joe Jr 13.5-inch	Real ceramic, small enough for a balcony	Ceramic	150 sq in (13.5 in)	75.6 lb (Amazon detail table)	Ceramic lifetime; metal and cast iron 5 yr; deflectors, stones and electronics 3 yr; thermometer and GASKETS 2 yr	4.6★ / 789	Check price →
Char-Griller AKORN Jr. 14-inch	Kamado shape for the price of a kettle	Triple-wall insulated steel — NOT ceramic	155 sq in	35.7 lb	5-year burn and rust-through; registration required; original purchaser only; EXCLUDES surface rust	4.6★ / 759	Check price →
Kamado Joe Big Joe I 24-inch	The 24-inch Joe at the 18-inch Joe's price	Ceramic	450 sq in (24 in)	353 lb (Amazon detail table)	Ceramic lifetime; metal and cast iron 5 yr; deflectors, stones and electronics 3 yr; thermometer and GASKETS 2 yr	4.6★ / 129	Check price →

Prices move constantly — any Amazon price shown is as of the date noted and subject to change; tap through for today's number.

The Egg is not cheaper, and the arithmetic is on the makers’ own pages

A Large Big Green Egg on its stand is $1,499.99 as Big Green Egg’s own nest package: the Egg, the Nest that holds it up, the convEGGtor that lets it cook indirect, a grid gripper, an ash tool, charcoal and starters. The Egg alone is a ceramic body that can do neither; bought piece by piece with its Nest and convEGGtor it comes to $1,549.97 on the same site, so take the package. A Kamado Joe Classic Joe II was $1,499.00 on Amazon the same day, 22 September 2026, and arrives with the cart, side shelves, heat deflectors and rack system in the box.

Serious Eats currently tells readers that the Large Big Green Egg “costs a few hundred dollars less” than the Classic Joe II. Equipped to cook, it costs the same, a dollar apart. And the nest is not optional paperwork: Big Green Egg’s terms say that placing an Egg on a combustible surface without a Big Green Egg nest, or “a 2” non-porous concrete block”, voids the warranty.

The warranty depends on who sold it

Both big ceramic brands warrant the ceramic for life, and both attach conditions that decide whether you ever collect.

Big Green Egg requires “a valid proof of purchase receipt from an Authorized Dealer”, excludes products bought from unauthorized resellers, voids the warranty if the Egg is not registered, voids it if lighter fluid is poured into the ceramic, and ships replacement parts at the purchaser’s expense.

Kamado Joe’s version is shorter and sharper: “Purchasing any Kamado Joe® product through an unauthorized dealer voids the warranty. An unauthorized dealer is defined as any retailer who has not been expressly granted permission by Kamado Joe® to sell Kamado Joe® products.” Kamado Joe publishes no list of who has permission. We found an Amazon buyer whose Joe Jr was sold by a marketplace seller and whose claim Kamado Joe refused on exactly those grounds. Every Kamado Joe we link was sold by Amazon.com itself when we first read it — the best case available on Amazon — and the seller on a listing does change: on 16 October 2026 the Classic Joe III’s listing had no Amazon.com offer, only two marketplace sellers. Read the “Sold by” line before you pay.

Kamado Joe’s own table also gives the gaskets and the thermometer two years, not the lifetime the headline implies. Those are the parts owners replace.

The classic size: 18 to 20 inches

This is the fight most buyers are having, and the one the rankings are about.

Best overall: Kamado Joe Classic Joe II

It wins on arriving rigged and on the deepest record of any ceramic grill here, not on cooking better than the Egg. The critical reviews are about the crate — ripped heat seals, a chipped firewall, broken heat deflectors — and about waiting on support, not about heat.

Winner

Our top pick

Kamado Joe Classic Joe II 18-inch

The one that arrives rigged · 18-inch ceramic kamado at about $1,499 with the cart, side shelves and heat deflectors already in the price — 4.7★ on 975 owners, the deepest ceramic base we read.

Your pick if you want a ceramic kamado that is ready to cook out of the crate, and you would rather pay once than discover the stand and the deflector are extra.

4.7 · 975 owner ratingsacross Amazon · 2026-09-22 · global base

Check price at Amazon →

Sold and shipped by Amazon · 30-day refund / replacement · read 2026-10-08

Picked before we checked what this link pays us.

Kamado Joe Classic Joe II 18-inch

The one that arrives rigged

Your pick if you want a ceramic kamado that is ready to cook out of the crate, and you would rather pay once than discover the stand and the deflector are extra.

4.7 · 975 owner ratingsAmazon · 2026-09-22 · global base

Pros

• Ships rigged — cart, shelves and heat deflectors are in the $1,499, which is the like-for-like comparison a Big Green Egg loses
• The deepest owner record of any true ceramic we read, 975 ratings at 4.7★, with only 4 percent at one star
• Sold and shipped by Amazon itself rather than a marketplace reseller, which matters on a brand that voids warranty on unauthorised-dealer purchases
• Ceramic carries a lifetime term, and the metal five years

Cons

• The gaskets and the thermometer — the two parts owners actually replace — get two years, not the lifetime the headline implies
• It is 228 lb of fragile freight and the tail says so: owners report ripped heat seals, a chipped firewall and two broken ceramic heat-deflector sets, all on arrival or early
• Support is the recurring complaint, not the cooking. One owner filed a damage claim through the website and was still waiting weeks later
• Nothing here is a cooking criticism. Consumer Reports found every kamado it tested makes great food, so the money question is delivery, parts and paperwork

What owners complain aboutTheme

It arrives damaged and then you have to chase someone. The critical tail is not about cooking: ripped heat seals top and bottom with the metal liner sticking out, a chipped ceramic firewall that Kamado Joe told the owner was fine, two ceramic heat-deflector sets broken under regular use, a bent side-table bracket whose warranty form went unanswered for weeks, and a third-party expedited shipment that took $278 and missed its window with no contact. Several owners say plainly that the grill itself is excellent and the ordering and support around it is not.

4 percent of owner ratings were one star at the 2026-09-12 read, when the base was 973 · critical reviews read 2026-09-12

Check price at Amazon →

Sold and shipped by Amazon · 30-day refund / replacement · read 2026-10-08

✓ Safety: no active recallNo CPSC recall found (recall API queried by ProductName=kamado on 2026-09-12: zero records). Category safety note that is NOT a recall: a kamado can flash over when you open a hot lid and oxygen rushes in, and lighter fluid soaks into the porous ceramic — on a Big Green Egg it also voids the warranty outright.

Best value ceramic: Kamado Joe Classic Joe I

The entry Classic is still a current Kamado Joe model, and it is the same 18-inch ceramic body and 250 square inches as the Classic II. You give up the three-piece rack system for a two-tier one. Its owner reviews are mostly about freight, including one brand-new unit that arrived with three of its five firebox walls cracked.

Kamado Joe Classic Joe I 18-inch

The $1,000 way into a Kamado Joe

Your pick if you want a true ceramic Kamado Joe on a cart for about a thousand dollars and can live with the two-tier rack instead of the Classic II's three-piece system.

4.6 · 360 owner ratingsAmazon · 2026-09-12 · global base

Pros

• About $500 under the Classic II for the same 18-inch ceramic body and cooking area
• A deep, clean owner record for the price — 360 ratings with 87 percent at five stars and 4 percent at one
• Sold and shipped by Amazon.com on the listing we link, not by a marketplace reseller
• Ceramic lifetime and metal five-year terms, the same paper as the dearer Classics

Cons

• It is the entry model, and one owner's critical review says so bluntly: they had not realised it was the older design and that the Classic II adds improvements
• Freight is the recurring problem, not cooking — missed delivery windows, a drive to the freight depot, and a split heat deflector, bent shelf bracket and chipped lid on arrival
• A brand-new unit in February 2025 arrived with three of its five firebox walls cracked and a rusty accessory rack
• The gaskets and thermometer carry two years, not the lifetime the headline implies

What owners complain aboutDefect reports

Freight and first-day condition. Owners describe scheduled deliveries that never came and a 60-mile drive to collect from the freight depot, and units arriving with a smashed split heat deflector, a bent shelf bracket and a chipped lid. A February 2025 buyer found three of five firebox walls cracked and the accessory rack rusty on a new grill. One long-term owner's dome cracked at about eighteen months, was replaced, and the grill never held temperature as well afterwards; a 2026 buyer found it hard to cure and the charcoal basket too small for long cooks.

4 percent of 360 owner ratings are one star as of 2026-09-12 (28 critical reviews) · critical reviews read 2026-09-12

Check price at Amazon →

✓ Safety: no active recallNo CPSC recall found (saferproducts.gov Recall API, 2026-09-12: ProductName=kamado, RecallTitle=kamado and ProductName=Kamado Joe all returned zero records; positive control ProductName=heater returned 181 in the same sitting). Category caution that is NOT a recall: flashover when a hot lid is opened, and never lighter fluid in a porous ceramic body.

Budget pick: Char-Griller AKORN 20-inch

The value answer in the category, with one honest asterisk: it is insulated steel, not ceramic. Its recent reviews add two more: rust on the grate and ash pan even under a cover, and quality control on assembly, including two owners in 2025 whose lid holes did not line up well enough to fit the thermometer. One buying note: choosing black instead of grey sends you to a separate Amazon page with a much lower score, built on reviews that stop in 2017.

Char-Griller AKORN 20-inch Kamado Charcoal Grill

Kamado shape, steel body, a third of the price

Your pick if you want kamado behaviour without ceramic money or ceramic weight, and you would rather replace a $400 grill in five years than freight a cracked 230 lb one back.

4.6 · 2,356 owner ratingsAmazon · 2026-10-26 · global base

Pros

• A third the price of a true ceramic and 88 lb against 228, so one person can move it and freight damage is not the risk it is on ceramic
• The deepest owner record in this post by a wide margin — 2,356 ratings at 4.6★
• Cart, wheels and warming rack are included rather than a $230 accessory
• Sold and shipped by Amazon itself

Cons

• It is not ceramic, and the post's whole premise is that this matters: steel heats and cools faster and will not hold a low overnight cook the way a ceramic body does
• The warranty covers burn and rust-THROUGH for five years and explicitly excludes surface rust — which is precisely what owners report, a grate they cannot keep from rusting on a covered deck
• It is top-heavy and tippy to move, the only handle is on the lid rather than the base, and an owner reports the handle pops out if it goes over and the latch does not reliably stay closed
• Cast iron cracking after a year, roof paint peeling, missing assembly hardware on back order, and — from two separate owners in August 2025 — lid holes that did not line up, so the thermometer could not be fitted; this is a $400 grill and its quality control shows it

What owners complain aboutTheme

Rust and balance, not heat. Owners on covered decks report grates they cannot keep from rusting even under a cover — which is exactly the failure the 5-year warranty excludes, because it covers rust-THROUGH and not surface rust. A cast iron grate cracked after a year. The roof coating peels. And several describe it as front- and top-heavy and tippy to wheel, with the only handle on the lid: one owner reports the handle popping out when it tipped, and a latch that does not reliably stay shut. Quality control is the other thread in 2025–2026: two owners could not install the thermometer because the inner and outer lid holes did not align, and a Christmas buyer received no assembly hardware at all, with the kit on back order.

at the September read, 5 percent of 2,349 owner ratings were one star · critical reviews read 2026-09-12

Check price at Amazon →

✓ Safety: no active recallNo CPSC recall found (recall API queried by ProductName=Char-Griller on 2026-09-12: zero records). Owner-reported tipping when moved, with the lid-mounted handle releasing, is a handling caution rather than a recall — wheel it by the base and keep the latch checked.

The name, priced honestly: Big Green Egg Large

A fine ceramic grill that, bought as Big Green Egg’s nest package, costs the same as the Classic Joe II — and whose warranty is the most conditional here. Big Green Egg sells it direct, so there is no Amazon owner rating to show you.

Big Green Egg Large in Nest Package

The name, and the warranty you have to read

Your pick if you want the Big Green Egg specifically, you will register it, and you will buy it from Big Green Egg or a listed dealer rather than whichever marketplace is cheapest.

Pros

• The ceramic carries a limited lifetime term and the brand has the deepest dealer and accessory network in the category
• Sells direct online with free delivery and 45-day returns, so the old “dealer-only” advice you will read elsewhere is out of date
• A full size ladder from Mini to 2XL, so the body is a platform rather than a single product

Cons

• Sold bare, the EGG does not stand up or cook indirect — buy the nest package, because the EGG, Nest and convEGGtor bought separately cost $1,549.97, fifty dollars more than the package
• The warranty is conditional in ways nobody prints: it requires a receipt from an Authorized Dealer, states that units from unauthorised resellers are NOT covered, and says failure to register “will invalidate your Warranty”
• Using lighter fluid voids it outright — the same lighter fluid every kamado safety guide already tells you never to use, a connection no buyer's guide makes
• Warranty replacements ship at the purchaser's expense, on a 162 lb ceramic item, and commercial use drops the term to one year

What owners complain aboutTheme

No independent owner base exists for us to read, because the EGG is not sold through a marketplace that publishes one. The documented catch on this product is not owner-reported at all — it is in the warranty terms and the accessory pricing, both of which are printed above from Big Green Egg's own pages.

Not applicable — no independent rating base · critical reviews read 2026-09-12

~$1,499.99typical at Big Green Egg · checked September 2026

Check price at Big Green Egg →

✓ Safety: no active recallNo CPSC recall found (recall API queried by ProductName=kamado on 2026-09-12: zero records). Big Green Egg's own warranty states that pouring lighter fluid onto or into an EGG voids coverage; the safety guidance against lighter fluid in porous ceramic and the warranty clause are the same fact.

The step-up: Kamado Joe Classic Joe III

When we read it in September, Amazon.com was selling the current Classic III for about fifty dollars more than the Classic II. On 16 October 2026 it was not: the listing showed no featured offer, and its only two sellers, both marketplace stores, asked $2,199.00, about what Kamado Joe charges on its own store. At that price, from sellers whose standing under Kamado Joe’s dealer clause nobody outside Kamado Joe can check, buy it from Kamado Joe. For the money you get the SloRoller insert and a three-tier rack. You also get a thinner owner record and a higher one-star share, and the tail is about the ceramic and the finish — a dome that came apart at high heat, paint that bubbled within six months and was refused under warranty — and about support that is hard to reach.

Kamado Joe Classic Joe III 18-inch

The three-tier Classic, with the SloRoller in the box

Your pick if you want the three-tier Divide & Conquer and the SloRoller in the box and will pay close to Kamado Joe’s list price for them — bought from Kamado Joe or a dealer it names while Amazon’s only sellers are marketplace stores.

4.5 · 267 owner ratingsAmazon · 2026-09-12 · global base

Pros

• The three-tier rack and SloRoller are genuinely more cooking system than the Classic II, and both are included
• Kamado Joe lists it on its own store, a buy path whose warranty standing is not in question
• Ceramic lifetime and metal five-year terms, the same paper as the Classic II

Cons

• A thinner record than the Classic II — 267 owner ratings against 973 — and a 7 percent one-star share against the II's 4
• The ceramic and the finish are where the tail lands: one owner's dome came apart at around 800 degrees, and another's side-table and top-vent paint bubbled within six months and was refused under warranty
• Support is hard to reach — owners describe no phone line, ignored tickets, and a harder time still if the grill was never registered
• Build and freight complaints repeat: a dome that will not stay shut without the latch, cart legs that twist when the grill is rolled, and a 280 lb crate left at the front door
• On 16 October 2026 Amazon.com was not selling it: the listing showed no featured offer, and its two marketplace sellers asked about Kamado Joe’s list price. Kamado Joe’s warranty excludes sellers it has not authorised and publishes no list to check them against.

What owners complain aboutDefect reports

The ceramic, the finish and the support, more than the cooking. One owner's dome came apart at around 800 degrees and a replacement was hard to get; another's side-table and top-vent paint bubbled within six months and Kamado Joe said paint was not covered. Others report a dome that will not stay closed without the latch, cart legs that twist when the grill is rolled, missing or bent parts across two deliveries, and no phone number to call. One buyer warns that Amazon delivers the crate to the front porch, not the patio.

7 percent of 267 owner ratings are one star as of 2026-09-12 (15 critical reviews) · critical reviews read 2026-09-12

Check price at Amazon →

✓ Safety: no active recallNo CPSC recall found (recall API queried by ProductName=kamado on 2026-09-12: zero records). Same category caution as any kamado: flashover on opening a hot lid, and never lighter fluid in a porous ceramic body.

The steel alternative we could not card: Weber Summit Kamado

Two credentialed testers name Weber’s insulated-steel kamado: Men’s Journal made the Summit Kamado S6 its best kamado of 2026, and AmazingRibs gives the E6 its top medal on a hands-on review. Owners suggest it as the kamado that will not crack. We did not card it because Weber’s own page read out of stock on 12 September 2026 and we could not confirm a place to buy it reliably. If you find one, it is the answer to “I want kamado cooking without two hundred pounds of fragile ceramic.”

Compact: 13 to 16 inches

For one to three people, a balcony, or a second grill.

Best compact: Kamado Joe Joe Jr

Real ceramic in a 76-pound grill, on a cast-iron stand with heat deflectors in the box, and the deepest owner record of any small ceramic kamado we read. It is slow to heat and reluctant to sear, and it is the Joe Jr whose Amazon buyer lost a warranty claim to a marketplace seller — check the seller.

Kamado Joe Joe Jr 13.5-inch

Real ceramic, small enough for a balcony

Your pick if you cook for one to three people, want true ceramic heat retention in a grill you can lift, and accept a slow heat-up and a small grate.

4.6 · 789 owner ratingsAmazon · 2026-10-18 · global base

Pro review “The bonus of this smaller version is that it’s also super quick to heat up: In our tests, it hit close to 700°F in 20 minutes.”Hands-on test of 14 portable charcoal grills; slot "The Best Portable Charcoal Kamado Grill"; buy link B00IJ74RBO, the listing we link. Quote matched 2026-10-18 (raw HTML).— Grace Kelly, Serious Eats

Pros

• Genuine ceramic in a 76 lb package, with the stand and heat deflectors in the box
• 789 owner ratings — far deeper than any other small ceramic kamado on Amazon
• Sold and shipped by Amazon.com on the listing we link
• The same lifetime-ceramic warranty table as the full-size Kamado Joes

Cons

• It is slow to heat and hard to take to a real sear, and one owner could not reach low-and-slow temperature with the deflector in without propping the lid
• Shipping damage is the dominant complaint — cracked fireboxes and chipped ceramic on arrival, with warranty replacements that took owners weeks or months
• It tips if the lid is opened before the grill is seated in its stand
• Buy it only where Amazon.com is the seller: an owner whose Joe Jr was shipped and sold by a marketplace seller was refused a warranty claim because that seller was not an authorised dealer

What owners complain aboutDefect reports

Arrival damage and slow warranty. Owners describe fireboxes cracked in the crate and chips in the ceramic, a replacement firebox that took two months of emails, and a 2026 chip Kamado Joe called cosmetic while Amazon sent the owner back to the maker. A 2024 buyer whose unit was sold by a marketplace seller was refused warranty because that seller was not an authorised Kamado Joe dealer. In use: slow to heat, reluctant to sear, and it can topple if the lid is opened off the stand.

5 percent of 789 owner ratings are one star as of 2026-10-18 (45 written critical reviews) · critical reviews read 2026-09-12

Check price at Amazon →

Sold and shipped by Amazon · read 2026-10-18

✓ Safety: no active recallNo CPSC recall found (saferproducts.gov Recall API, 2026-09-12: ProductName=kamado, RecallTitle=kamado and ProductName=Kamado Joe returned zero records; positive control ProductName=heater returned 181). Category caution, not a recall: flashover on a hot lid, and no lighter fluid in porous ceramic.

Budget compact: Char-Griller AKORN Jr.

The kamado shape for the price of a kettle, light enough to carry. It is steel, it rusts — one Florida owner’s second Akorn Jr was rusting at the damper after five months under a cover — and new units arrive with missing latches, misaligned lids and flaking porcelain often enough to plan on inspecting it. Char-Griller does sell nearly every part on its own site.

Char-Griller AKORN Jr. 14-inch

Kamado shape for the price of a kettle

Your pick if you want to learn kamado cooking for under $200, or need a kamado one person can carry, and you accept a steel body that rusts and a quality-control lottery on assembly.

4.6 · 759 owner ratingsAmazon · 2026-10-18 · global base

Pro review “Though the pan is only sized for a small coal bed, we were still able to sear steaks at 500 ℉ within minutes of getting the coals up to temperature.”Hands-on scored test of 13 charcoal grills; award "Best Tabletop Charcoal Grill"; buy link B08GTTMZ41, the listing we link. Quote matched 2026-10-18 (raw HTML).— Ross Patton, TechGearLab

Pros

• Under $200 for kamado-style cooking, a fraction of any ceramic
• 35.7 lb — one person can carry it
• A deep owner record for a small grill — 759 ratings on the listing we link
• Char-Griller sells nearly every part on its own site — firegrate, damper kit, latch kit, legs, hinge, thermometer — mostly in stock

Cons

• It is steel, not ceramic: faster up and down, less forgiving on a long low cook
• Rust is the long-term story — a Florida owner's second Akorn Jr started rusting at the damper in five months under a cover, and the 5-year term covers rust-through, not surface rust
• Quality control is uneven: owners report missing latches and legs, flaking porcelain and misaligned lids on new units
• Parts are sold, but one owner in Hawaii was told the company does not ship parts there

What owners complain aboutDefect reports

Rust and quality control. A Florida owner's second Akorn Jr began rusting at the damper after five months under a cover. New units arrive with missing ash-pan latches, an extra leg and no lid handle, porcelain flaking inside the lid and base, dents, and lids that do not line up with the body. One owner was told a brand-new unit was past warranty and that parts are not shipped to Hawaii.

37 critical reviews on the grey listing as of 2026-09-12 · critical reviews read 2026-09-12

Check price at Amazon →

Sold and shipped by Amazon · read 2026-10-18

✓ Safety: no active recallNo CPSC recall found (saferproducts.gov Recall API, 2026-09-12: ProductName=Akorn and RecallTitle=Char-Griller returned zero records; positive control ProductName=heater returned 181).

The cheap 15-inch ceramic we do not recommend

The London Sunshine 15-inch ceramic kamado is cheaper than the Joe Jr, rates well, and its happy owners call it well built. Its unhappy owners describe grills arriving with broken bases and cracked lids, and the newest, in August 2026, a firebox that broke on the second use and a replacement part promised for four months that never came. The seller’s own parts store listed that firebox and the 15-inch base as unavailable when we checked. Its warranty terms page describes the terms for products “sold Internationally, with exception of North American, South America and China”. A ceramic grill is freight that sometimes breaks; this one has nobody we could find standing behind it.

Big: 22 to 24 inches

For a crowd, a whole packer brisket, or two zones with room to spare.

Best big: Kamado Joe Big Joe I

A 24-inch ceramic grill with 450 square inches of grate, on a cart, for the same price as the 18-inch Classic Joe II on Amazon. It arrives as a pallet of more than 350 pounds, and owners describe carriers who could not move it — plan the route to the patio before it ships.

Kamado Joe Big Joe I 24-inch

The 24-inch Joe at the 18-inch Joe's price

Your pick if you regularly cook for a crowd, want ceramic, and would rather spend Classic II money on a 24-inch grate than on the Classic's accessories.

4.6 · 129 owner ratingsAmazon · 2026-09-12 · global base

Pros

• 450 sq in of ceramic grill for the same money as the 250 sq in Classic Joe II
• Sold and shipped by Amazon.com on the listing we link
• Only 5 percent one-star across 129 owner ratings
• Ceramic lifetime and metal five-year terms

Cons

• It arrives as a pallet of more than 350 lb, and owners describe carriers who could not move it — plan the route to the patio and the help before it ships
• One owner could not get the lid to seal at the back even after adjusting the bands and hinge
• A thin record for a $1,500 grill — 129 ratings — and the accessories that make a 24-inch kamado versatile are sold separately and priced like it
• The gaskets and thermometer carry two years, not the lifetime the headline implies

What owners complain aboutFit / placement

The freight and the fit. A 400 lb pallet arrives with carriers who cannot move it — one owner helped haul the crate because the pallet jack failed, another had to remove a patio door. One owner could not make the lid seal at the back despite adjusting the bands and hinge. An older unit's firebox cracked up one side after about eight months, and owners warn that the accessories cost the grill all over again.

5 percent of 129 owner ratings are one star as of 2026-09-12 (6 critical reviews) · critical reviews read 2026-09-12

Check price at Amazon →

✓ Safety: no active recallNo CPSC recall found (saferproducts.gov Recall API, 2026-09-12: ProductName=kamado, RecallTitle=kamado and ProductName=Kamado Joe all returned zero records; positive control ProductName=heater returned 181 in the same sitting). Category caution that is NOT a recall: flashover when a hot lid is opened, and never lighter fluid in a porous ceramic body.

The two alternatives cost more once they can cook. A Big Green Egg XL is $1,649.99, and Big Green Egg’s own XL nest is another $249.99, or $2,049.99 as its XL nest package. A Primo Oval XL 400 — American-made and the only oval, which gives it a real two-zone fire — is sold through dealers; the one Primo names in Wichita listed the grill head at $1,619 and the All-In-One with its cradle and shelves at $2,299, and Primo ships warranty replacement parts at the purchaser’s expense.

The skips

Kamado Joe Konnected Joe. The fan-controlled Classic won short tests. Serious Eats’ year-long test found its fan stopped working at about six months, owners describe melted fans and tripped breakers, and the Amazon listing we read was offered by a marketplace seller rather than Amazon.com — the channel Kamado Joe’s warranty excludes. Buy a Classic and a separate fan controller if you want automation.

Grilla Grills Kong. A genuine ceramic kamado at about $1,000, sold against Kamado Joe, Big Green Egg and Primo, all of which warrant ceramic for life. Grilla’s warranty page covers “all other grills” for four years. Its Amazon listing had six ratings when we read it. We have not carded it.

Next showdown

Keep the fight going

Catchweight

Grills, Smokers, and Pizza

The Best Portable Charcoal Grills (2026): Jumbo Joe vs Rambler, and the Tested Winners You Can't Buy

Ten portable charcoal grills read on their own listings on 18 October 2026, every critical revi…

Updated Oct 2026

Catchweight

Grills, Smokers, and Pizza

The Best Gravity-Fed Smokers (2026): The Masterbuilt 1150 Two Test Kitchens Liked, Food & Wine's AutoIgnite 545, and Three Burn Times on One Hopper

Seven gravity-fed charcoal smokers read signed in on their own Amazon listings on 17 October 20…

Updated Oct 2026

Welterweight · $729–$1,220

Grills, Smokers, and Pizza

The Best Offset Smokers Over $700 (2026): Longhorn Reverse Flow vs Broil King Regal, and the Steel Only Two Makers Print

Offset smokers from $700 to $1,000 read on their own listings on 18 October 2026, every critica…

Updated Oct 2026

Pound-for-Pound

Grills, Smokers, and Pizza

recteq Staq vs Grilla Mammoth vs Pit Boss Navigator 6: The Best Vertical Pellet Smoker of 2026

The Grilla Mammoth is the best vertical pellet smoker of 2026: a tester's overnight cook at 225…

Updated Oct 2026